Joint Employer Debate Reignites as Department of Labor Moves to Set Clearer Standard

The joint employer rule is up for debate once again. On Wednesday, the U.S. Department of Labor moved to establish a unified standard for determining joint employer status under the Fair Labor Standards Act and align it with the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act. The move—featuring stricter guidelines supported by the restaurant franchise community—is designed to address a longstanding lack of regulatory clarity and inconsistent interpretations across federal courts. “Under President Trump’s leadership, the Department of Labor is committed to simplifying compliance for American employers and strengthening protections to put American workers first,” acting labor secretary Keith Sonderling said in a statement. “A clear standard on joint employment would give businesses more confidence to invest in partnerships, help employees understand their rights, and make the department’s investigations more efficient.” The Department of Labor’s proposal takes a more structured approach and draws heavily from federal court precedent. It formally distinguishes between “horizontal” and “vertical” joint employment. These are two concepts courts have long recognized but have not always been applied consistently. Horizontal joint employment would apply when two employers are sufficiently associated with respect to the same employee. However, the department makes clear that common business arrangements, like franchisees operating under the same brand or businesses sharing vendors, are not enough on their own to establish that relationship. The more consequential test for restaurant operators is likely to be the vertical joint employment analysis, which is the relationship between a worker and…

Continue reading →